For the first time in history, the Abbotsford Trust has named an all British shortlist for the Walter Scott Prize. Finalists include a moving tribute and a novel impossible to forget.
In a historic first for the prestigious Walter Scott literary prize, every book named on the 2026 shortlist is by a British author.
The announcement was made on 16 April from Abbotsford, the ancestral home of Sir Walter Scott, via a video narrated by the veteran broadcaster James Naughtie. Over the award’s seventeen-year history, the shortlist has never before featured an exclusively British line-up.
The five finalists competing for the title are Jo Harkin, Alice Jolly, Graeme Macrae Burnet, Rachel Seiffert, and Benjamin Wood. This year’s selection traverses a vast emotional and historical landscape, from the “bawdy” coming-of-age of a medieval pretender to the “unflinching historical realism” of 1930s Vienna.
READ MORE: Best paperbacks to read now including a ‘cult phenomenon’ everybody is readingREAD MORE: The Radio 2 Book Club Award 2026 shortlist in full as Sara Cox names the eight finalists
Jo Harkin’s The Pretender reimagines the life of Lambert Simnel, the boy who would be king. The judges described the work as a “rich, brilliant, fresh, bawdy novel” that follows its protagonist from farm boy to usurper, kitchen boy, and eventually a “vengeful lothario,” noting that it is “both convincing and very very funny.”
In contrast, Alice Jolly’s The Matchbox Girl offers a “moving tribute to a lost generation of children under Nazi rule.” Centred on a young girl in a 1930s Austrian hospital, the judges praised the novel as a “sharp examination of Dr Hans Asperger’s legacy” that manages to balance “vivid imagining of the beginnings of autism diagnosis” with a narrator who is “impossible to forget.”
The shortlist also ventures into the dark, gothic territory of the Outer Hebrides with Graeme Macrae Burnet’s Benbecula. Set in the mid-nineteenth century, the psychological novella examines a brutal triple murder.
The panel hailed it as “claustrophobic crime at its very best,” noting that it takes “its literary lead from the early innovators of the modern novel, James Hogg and Robert Louis Stevenson.”
Want to hear the latest books news and reviews from The Mirror’s resident bookworm? Follow Aimée Walsh on Tiktok and Instagram
Rachel Seiffert’s Once the Deed is Done shifts the focus to a post-war displaced persons camp. The judges called it an “outstanding novel” that explores the fate of millions of slave workers in Nazi Germany.
They remarked that the book is “full of feeling but without sentimentality” as characters “detach themselves from the Nazi state of mind and begin to take in the horror of what their country has done.”
The final contender is Benjamin Wood’s Seascraper, a story set on England’s northwest coast. Focusing on a shrimp shanker named Thomas Flett, the judges lauded Wood as a novelist who proves “small lives make big stories.” They described the work as a “rich read, one to be savoured,” highlighting the tension of a life “thirled to a habit” in a landscape of “drudging” work and treacherous “sinkpits.”
Literary enthusiasts will not have long to wait for the final result. The winner of the prize is scheduled to be announced at the Borders Book Festival in Melrose on 12 June.
Love reading? Join Dr. Aimée Walsh and our community of fellow readers in the Mirror Book Club to dive deeper into the books everyone is talking about.
